A BIRD no larger than a cricket ball could derail plans to
build the biggest coal mine in Australia.
A legal
challenge to Indian giant Adani’s plans for the $16.5 billion Carmichael mine
by environment group Coast and Country began in the Land Court of Queensland on
Tuesday.
If approved, the
project would extract at least 50 million tonnes of coal a year from the
Galilee Basin and export it through the Abbot Point coal terminal, north of
Bowen.
“The
environmental harm it will cause, or is at risk of causing, will be correspondingly
great,” lawyer Saul Holt QC, for Coast and Country, told the court.
The case will
put the spotlight on environmental and economic concerns, including the plight
of the endangered Black-Throated Finch.
The one species that could change the face of mining: A Black-throated Finch.
Map showing the location of the proposed Carmichael mine near Bowen and Mackay in Queensland.
“If this
mine goes ahead ... there is a high likelihood of species-threatening harm to
the world’s most significant population of the endangered Black-Throated
Finch,” Mr Holt said.
“As an
environmental issue and risk, it is of the first order and it will be treated
as such.”
The mine would
also have an effect on the threatened Waxy Cabbage Palm and may dry up the
nearby Doongmabulla Springs, opponents argue.
But
lawyer Peter Ambrose, for Adani, defended the company’s environmental modelling
and previewed evidence by a range of experts in his opening address.
The company
accepts there has been a serious decline in finch populations — which Mr Holt
said was 80 per cent since the 1980s. But Adani pointed to offset and
management plans that would “provide appropriate controls on the environmental
impact”.
In exchange for
the 9789 hectares of habitat that would be affected by the mine, there was an
offset area of 30,999ha, Mr Ambrose said.
“The applicant’s
evidence is they don’t have to move too far, as the offset areas are right
beside where they are known to breed.”
Mr Ambrose cited
estimates the mine could produce net economic benefits of between $18.6 billion
and $22.8 billion.
But Mr
Holt said the project would also contribute to the degradation of the Great
Barrier Reef through a contribution to climate change.
Adani’s
witnesses will argue that thermal coal use is generated by demand — not supply
— and electricity generators would find alternative sources of coal if the mine
does not go ahead.
Therefore, Adani
argues, there will be no net increase in greenhouse gas emissions.
The project would also contribute to the degradation of the Great Barrier Reef through a contribution to climate change, lawyers argue
No comments:
Post a Comment