GERMAN prosecutors revealed the “significant discovery”
made at Germanwing co-pilot Andreas Lubitz’s home was a sick note covering the
day of the crash.
Prosecutors
found “torn-up and current sick leave notices” suggesting he was ill and
receiving medical treatment, backing up suspicions he hid his illness from his
employer and colleagues.
While
investigators did not specify what illness Lubitz had, German media reports he
needed ongoing assessments for severe depression, BBC reports.
Duesseldorf
prosecutors said in a statement that “interviews on this subject and the
evaluation of medical records will take several more days”, and that the
outcome would be made public “once reliable evidence is available”.
Authorities did
not find a “suicide note or a confession”, or any evidence that the co-pilot’s
actions may have been motivated by “a political or religious background”.
Officers had on
Thursday combed through a flat Andreas Lubitz kept in Duesseldorf as well as
the house where he lived with his parents in the small western town of
Montabaur.
The news comes
following revelations the captain, Patrick Sonderheimer, used an axe to break
down the cockpit’s armoured door when he was locked out on the day of the
crash.
This could not
be immediately confirmed, but a spokesman for Germanwings confirmed to AFP that
an axe was on board the aircraft. Such a tool is “part of the safety equipment
of an A320,” the spokesman told German daily Bild.
Lubitz
reportedly suffered a major breakdown following a recent relationship
breakdown.
According to The Telegraph in the UK, Lubitz was engaged to be
married next year, but had recently broken up with his fiancee. It is
understood that the 28-year-old was struggling to cope after the relationship
failed.
The
theory emerged hours after The Guardian reported Lubitz stopped his
training to be a pilot six years ago because he was suffering from
“psychological problems”.
The report,
quoted from German daily Bild, said the Lufthansa flight school in Phoenix
designated Lubitz at the time as “not suitable for flying”.
Yesterday,
police announced they had made a “significant discovery” at Lubitz’s home in
Dusseldorf.
German media
also reported that police were investigating one particular piece of paper
which they believe held clues to Lubitz’s horrific actions.
Markus Niesczery
of Dusseldorf Police told the Daily Mail:
“We wanted to search to see if we could find something that would explain what
happened.”
“We have found
something which will now be taken for tests. We cannot say what it is at the
moment but it may be a very significant clue to what has happened,” Mr Niesczery
said.
No other details
were released by local officials however.
CNN also reported transponder data revealed the autopilot on the doomed flight was reprogrammed by someone in the cockpit to change the plane’s altitude from 38,000 feet to 100 feet, according to Flightradar24.
Prosecutors say
Lubitz deliberately crashed the passenger plane, killing 150 people.
Marseilles
prosecutor Brice Robin said the 28-year-old German crashed the plane “intentionally” and locked the captain out of the
cockpit on Tuesday.
Now the mother
of Lubitz’s former classmate says he was forced to postpone pilot training
around 2009 and suffered from “burnout or depression”.
“I can
only image the whole thing was a knee-jerk reaction. It can’t have been
planned, although it was actually like a killing spree,” she told The Mirror.
In a press
conference overnight, Lufthansa CEO Carsten Spohr confirmed that Lubitz had
taken several months off work without disclosing why, but said he was
considered mentally and physically fit to fly.
He said Lubitz
had passed all psychological tests required to begin training and underwent
regular physical examinations.
A Spiegel
reporter, Matthias Gebauer, tweeted that friend of Lubitz said he had “burnout
or depression” in 2009 and took a break from his pilot training.
Mr Spohr said
that it appears the captain punched in the emergency number into the cockpit
door to gain entry, but the co-pilot deployed the five-minute override.
Mr Robin
said there is no indication this was an act of terrorism, but stopped short of
declaring it suicide, saying only it was a “legitimate” question to ask.
On the question
of suicide, Mr Spohr said: “We can only speculate what might have been the
motivation of the co-pilot. In a company that prides itself on its safety
record, this is a shock. We select cockpit personnel carefully.”
Mr Robin refused
to give details on the pilot’s religion or ethnic background, saying: “I don’t
think it’s necessarily what we should be looking for.”
Lubitz lived
with his parents in Montabaur and also kept an apartment in Dusseldorf, a
Germanwings hub, according to Montabaur mayor Gabriele Wieland.
The town
of Montabaur published a news release on Thursday expressing sympathy with the
family, although it did not name Lubitz.
At the house
believed to be his parents’, the curtains were drawn and four police cars were
parked outside. Police kept the media away from the door of the Montabaur home.
Neighbour
Johannes Rossmann said Lubitz appeared to be in good health and was a regular
jogger. He described the pilot as calm and low-key.
“I do not
believe he killed himself and claimed other people’s lives,” the 22-year-old
Rossmann said. “I can’t believe it until it is 100 per cent confirmed.”
Lubitz was also
identified by a flight club at which he was a member, according to theWall
Street Journal.
“Andreas became
a member of the club as a youth to fulfil his dream of flying,” the
Luftsportclub Westerwald said in a death notice on its website. “He began as a
gliding student and made it to become a pilots on an Airbus 320.”
“He
fulfilled his dream, the dream he now paid for so dearly with his life,” the
club said.
“He was happy he
had the job with Germanwings and he was doing well,” glider club member Peter
Ruecker told the Independent. “He
gave off a good feeling.”
Ruecker said
that he remembers Lubitz as “rather quiet but friendly” when he first showed up
at the club as a 14 or 15-year-old.
Club chairman
Klaus Radke said he rejected French prosecutors’ conclusion that Lubitz put the
Germanwings flight intentionally into a descent when the pilot had left the
cockpit.
“I don’t see how
anyone can draw such conclusions before the investigation is completed,” he
said.
Ruecker said
Lubitz also trained in Phoenix, Arizona, and had a girlfriend but did not have
many more details about his life. A recently deleted Facebook page bearing
Lubitz’s name showed him as a smiling man posing in front of the Golden Gate
Bridge in California.
Lubitz
joined Germanwings in September 2013 and had about 630 flight hours. He joined
Germanwings straight from the Lufthansa Flight Training School in Bremen,the London Telegraph reports.
Lubitz first
worked as a flight attendant, according to Thomas Winkelmann, the Greenwings
managing director, who said there was nothing unusual in the results of
Lubitz’s training.
A 2013
article in the Aviation Business Gazette reported the US Federal Aviation
Administration’s (FAA) inclusion of Lubitz in the prestigious FAA Airmen
Certification Database, for having “met or exceeded the high educational,
licensing and medical standards established by the FAA”.
“FAA pilot
certification can be the difference between a safe flight and one that ends in
tragedy,” the journal says.
Mr Robin
outlined Lubitz’s actions for the press in a chilling account of the plane’s
last 20 minutes.
“For the first
20 minutes of the flight, the pilots spoke in a normal way, you could say
cheerful and courteous,” Mr Robin said. “We heard the flight commander prepare
the briefing for landing at Dusseldorf and the response of the co-pilot seemed
laconic. Then we heard the commander ask the co-pilot to take the controls.
The captain has
been identified as Patrick Sonderheimer. According to Bild and Europe1, Sonderheimer was
married and the father of two children. He had more than 6000 flight hours,
mostly on Airbus jets.
Mr Robin said
the co-pilot’s responses, initially courteous, became “curt” when the captain
began the mid-flight briefing on the planned landing of the Germanwings flight
which crashed in France, killing 150 people.
Mr Robin
told a press conference the actions that took the plane down occurred during the
last eight minutes of the flight.
While the
co-pilot was alone at the controls, he initiated the descent of the plane,
selecting the altitude in such a way that could only have occurred
deliberately.
“Forty-eight
hours after the crash … the interpretation for us is that the co-pilot
deliberately refused to open the door of the cockpit to the flight commander,
and pushed the button causing a loss of altitude.”
“We heard
several calls from the flight commander asking for access to the cockpit,” Mr
Robin said. “There was a visual and audio interphone and he identified himself.
There was no response from the co-pilot.
“We heard at the same time the sound of a seat being pushed back
and the sound of a door closing.”
Mr Robin said Lubitz could be heard breathing right up until the
point of impact, suggesting he had not lost consciousness. However, he failed
to respond to increasingly desperate calls from the commander trying to break
down the cockpit door, or to air traffic controllers.
AUSTRALIA REVIEWS COCKPIT SAFETY PROCEDURES
Australian aviation authorities will review cockpit security
procedures in the wake of the horrific Germanwings’ crash.
Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Infrastructure and
Regional Development Warren Truss said the review would consider whether any
changes were needed to regulations that allowed pilots to be left alone in the
cockpit for brief periods.
Already several overseas carriers have changed their policy, to
ensure no-one is ever left alone in the flight deck.
Since the September 11 attacks, US carriers have been required
to have a flight attendant take the pilot or co-pilot’s place when they leave
the cockpit for a toilet break, or other reason.
“Careful consideration needs to be made following thorough
investigation to ensure that altering current procedures does not open other
potential vulnerabilities,” Mr Truss said.
“Our two
major international and domestic airlines are undertaking their own safety and
security risk assessments of cockpit procedures following the recent tragedy.”
Mr Truss said
Australian travellers should have confidence in the strict safety regulations
already in place to safeguard passengers.
“We take a
preventive, layered approach to aviation security,” he said.
“Airline pilots
are psychologically tested as part of their recruitment process.
“Pilots must
also undergo at least annual medical, including mental health checks under
Civil Aviation Safety Authority licence requirements.”
A Qantas Group
spokesman said they were “monitoring the information coming out of the French
investigation and considering if any changes to our existing safeguards are
needed”.
“This includes
discussions with regulators,” he said.
No comments:
Post a Comment